The age threshold enables an assessment; it does not replace it.
Someone under 14 when an act occurs is not criminally responsible under section 19 of the Criminal Code. At the 14th birthday, criminal responsibility becomes possible for juveniles. The relevant age is the age at the time of the act, rather than only at a later hearing.
Under section 3 of the Youth Courts Act, a juvenile’s moral and intellectual development also matters. Youth criminal law particularly directs its responses towards preventing further offences. Section 5 first identifies educational measures, with disciplinary measures or youth imprisonment subject to further conditions.

The other three answers
Personal responsibility is not the same as adult criminal law.
are treated like adults.
Those aged 14 to under 18 are not simply treated as adults. The special rules of the Youth Courts Act apply.
share the punishment with their parents.
Punishment is not automatically shared with parents. Whether another person has responsibility of their own would be a separate legal question.
are not punished.
A general absence of criminal responsibility from 14 is incorrect. Juveniles can be held responsible under the statutory conditions.
The short exam answer is not a promise of automatic punishment.
The catalogue’s wording is highly compressed. In practice, the offence, culpability and other requirements must be established. Educational measures must also not simply be equated with youth imprisonment.
The age groups remain distinct: the Act defines juveniles as 14 to under 18 and young adults as 18 to under 21. Further special rules apply to young adults. Lack of criminal responsibility under 14 likewise does not make harmful conduct permissible or remove every other possible consequence.
Section 3 · Responsibility · Youth Courts Act ↗From 14: possible responsibility under youth criminal law.
Remember the age threshold while keeping the maturity assessment and the different statutory responses in mind.
Three words for this question
- strafmündigcapable of criminal responsibility
- Old enough to be capable of criminal responsibility subject to further legal conditions.
- die Tatzeittime of the act
- The time at which an act is committed.
- die Erziehungsmaßregeleducational measure
- A statutory educational response in youth criminal law.
